"World Cinema: Israel"

My book, "World Cinema: Israel" (originally published in 1996) is available from Amazon on "Kindle", with an in-depth chapter comparing and analyzing internationally acclaimed Israeli films up to 2010.

Want to see some of the best films of recent years? Just scroll down to "best films" to find listings of my recommendations.

amykronish@gmail.com

Showing posts with label ultra-orthodox society. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ultra-orthodox society. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

This year’s Graduation films of the Ma’aleh Film school’s Ultra-orthodox track

In the framework of the Jerusalem Jewish Film Festival, I went to see the graduating films of the Ultra-orthodox women filmmakers who have been studying at Ma’aleh.  The films were varied – documentary and fiction – and dealt with a wide range of subjects. Seven short films were screened.  All of them were compelling and provocative and succeeded in portraying important issues.

An award for outstanding student filmmaker was presented to Esti Viye.  She directed two films that were screened today:

  • ·       Happily Ever After (13 minutes, drama) – Shira is a young mother who has left her kids with her parents and has organized a romantic anniversary getaway with her husband, who is a reserve soldier. She is excited to see him and is terribly disappointed as reality sets in and their time together is cut short.  Shira is finding it hard to hold it together.  This film really talked to me because there were so many miluim families in Israel who were traumatized and severely affected by the demands of the war of the last two years.
  • ·       The Lifeguard (13 minutes, documentary) – Esti’s father is a lifeguard and he loves the water.  But Esti finds it difficult to enter the pool or the sea.  In trying to reconnect with her father over a past trauma, she realizes she must overcome her fear of the water.

There were two films by filmmaker Bat Sheva Haddad:

  • ·       Houses of Silence (20 minutes, documentary) – The filmmaker and her daughter go on a personal journey documenting the homes in their neighborhood in Gedera which are hiding terrible secrets about babies who were kidnapped during the early years of the State.
  • ·       He’s Coming (8 minutes, drama) – A story about abuse in the home. Before their father comes home, we can already feel that the mother and two daughters are afraid of him.  When he arrives, the 12-year-old takes her younger sister and runs away, while in the background we hear the father abusively yelling at their mother.

There were two films by filmmaker Sarah Libah Hanfling:

  • ·       The Bride (15 minutes, drama) -– In the weeks leading up to her wedding, a woman, who has been previously married and traumatized, is grappling with her fears.
  • ·       Still Here (14 minutes, drama) – A young mother is exhausted, depressed and overworked and finds herself pregnant again.  Out of despair, she contemplates suicide. A stunning performance by the actress, Tamar Diskin.

One more film was directed by Chayaleh Arnster:

  • ·       Unacceptable (15 minutes, drama) -- Moishe is a yeshiva student and he loves music.  His parents are arranging a match for him but he only has eyes for Ayala.  In a world in which you can only get married by shidduch, he has to come up with a plan.

 

 

 

Wednesday, September 6, 2023

A New Feature Film about the Haredi Community

 Home, directed by Benny Fredman, screenplay written by Benny Fredman and Dror Keren, is a film about greed and hypocrisy within the Jerusalem haredi community.  The story is about a newly-wed couple, Yair and Nava, who are trying to find their way by building a mutually understanding relationship and a warm and loving home.  The story is based on a real event that happened to the filmmaker, when he was a young man, living with his new wife in Geula, which is an over-crowded, haredi neighborhood in the center of Jerusalem. 

The film begins with Yair studying at a kolel (yeshiva) for married men, but he is dreaming of opening a computer store.  When he opens his first store, he is met with a few surprises.  One of them is Nava’s disappointment at the fact that her husband is no longer a torah scholar.  Another is the neighborhood committee which is demanding protection money under the guise of inspecting that he isn’t selling anything that will undermine the morals of the community’s young people.  Yair agrees immediately to selling only computers and MP-3 players (remember those?) which are not connected to the internet or to radio.  As his business grows, the amount of protection money doubles.  Then the terms change, and the committee wants a bigger pound of flesh, but Yair isn’t so willing to play the game. 

In his remarks following the screening of his film, the filmmaker said: “I tried to show both sides, the side of the hero and the side of the head of the neighborhood committee who wants to protect the children of the neighborhood.  I tried to show the complexity of a man who finds himself fighting against his community, his family, everything he knows.”

Home (110 minutes, 2023) is a gripping thriller, with wonderful pacing. The viewer is drawn in and really cares about the characters who are seen with depth and lots of personality.  But most importantly, it is a based-on-real-life look at navigating one’s life within a tight-knit haredi community. The film is available from Go2Films. 

 

Wednesday, March 29, 2023

A Coming-of-Age Film

 An adolescent boy, a recent Ukrainian immigrant mother, and a Chabad shaliach, are all in the same room...  This could be the beginning of a great joke!

Rather, it is the beginning of a compelling film, More than I Deserve, directed by Pini Tavger.  The film tells the story of a single mother, recently arrived from the Ukraine, her adolescent son and their encounter with a Chabad representative. All three main characters are complex characters who offer authentic portrayals. 

Tamara and her son, Pinchas, live in Haifa, in a shabby apartment.  Tamara works as a night cleaning lady in the hospital and she is lonely, depressed, poorly paid, and drinks too much.  She is having an affair with a married man, whom she is pressing to leave his wife.  We know the chances of that happening.

Pinchas is a bit of an outcast with the other boys in his grade. When he sees that they are all going for bar mitzvah lessons with the Chabad representative in the neighborhood, he wants to be part of that.  His mother, at first, is adamantly opposed to anything having to do with Chabad and forbids her son to participate.  Pinchas, however, begins lessons behind her back, and eventually his Chabad teacher, Shimon, becomes an integral part of their lives. 

The presence of Shimon, who himself had been a drug addict before Chabad saved him, changes things for the family.  He becomes close to Pinchas, sort of a father replacement, and eventually becomes close to Tamara too. 

The title of the film refers to something Shimon says to Tamara when she asks him why he’s not married, after all, he is a religious man and not so young.  He explains about the drug addiction in his past, and he says, “I want more than I deserve,” referring to the fact that he is damaged goods and they are setting him up with girls who are also apparently not so perfect. 

There is an inherent criticism of Chabad due to its tradition of arranged marriages, even in this day and age, and Shimon himself is caught up in his rabbi’s insistence that he marry the girl who has been chosen for him. 

More than I Deserve premiered at the 2021 Jerusalem Film Festival where it won the prize for best screenplay. The filmmaker should be congratulated for his nuanced look at the hardships facing new immigrants.

Thursday, August 29, 2019

The Story of a Public Housing Building in Jerusalem


In The Stars of Stern, filmmaker Gad Abittan documents a public housing building which is going through drastic change.  The building, located in the Kiryat Yovel neighborhood of western Jerusalem, is home to the filmmaker, who narrates the film with a lot of humor and charm.

I especially liked the fact that the filmmaker mixes his own personal story with the story of the building.  He talks about his aliyah from Morocco via Youth Aliyah in the 1960s and his handicap as a result of being seriously wounded while serving in the Israeli army.

We meet diverse and fascinating tenants – some of them renters and some owners, some veteran Israelis, particularly from North African countries like Morocco, and some recent immigrants.  We meet Clara, a veteran, who is the "soul of the building", running the house committee for many years; an elderly couple, recent immigrants from the Former Soviet Union, who live a very lonely existence in this building; Moshe, from Morocco, who lives with his brother and is very playful with many of the neighbors, some of whom think that he might be somewhat disturbed.  We are witness to some poignant shared moments between the neighbors, and also some disturbing funerals.

Abittan tells the viewer that the film started out as a love letter to his building and its residents, and eventually became a letter of farewell.  We begin to understand the meaning of the farewell, when his neighbors begin to move out.  In 2008, ultra-orthodox (haredi) families began moving in.  Their families are quite large, and the apartments are too small.  They leave their strollers and bikes in the entrance hallway, and the veteran residents complain.  

Demanding respect from the secular Jews, the religious Jews begin to impose their lifestyle on the others within the public sphere – insisting that the women dress modestly, for example, which causes friction and arguments.  As the tensions rise, more and more people decide to leave the building, and even more haredim move in. Today, the building is 70% haredi – the turnover took place in just under 10 years.  When Clara decided to move out, Abittan admits that things were no longer the same. And he himself has decided to move to Tel Aviv, but it is very difficult to find affordable housing there.

This is a moving human story of identity and displacement in an old Jerusalem neighborhood. I found it to be compelling but sad.

The Stars of Stern (documentary, 60 minutes) is available from the filmmaker, Gad Abittan –

Thursday, January 3, 2019

The Other Story by Avi Nesher


Avi Nesher is one of Israel’s greatest and most prolific filmmakers.  In his early years, he was well-known for Sing Your Heart Out (HaLahaka).  After a long period working in Hollywood, he returned to Israel where he has made some of the more important films of the last 25 years: Turn Left at the End of the World, Secrets, Wonders, and Past Life.

According to the publicity for his latest film, The Other Story, it’s about a young woman who is becoming haredi (ultra-orthodox) and her parents want to prevent her from marrying, because, let’s face it, marrying someone from the haredi world would probably be an irreversible commitment for her. But the film is not only about that. It’s about so much more.   

It is a gripping complex narrative film that follows two family stories.  Both stories are about relations between parents and children, and explore whether any of us really can know what’s best for our children. 

Anat and Shahar were a couple when they were secular, even hedonistic, youngsters.  Today, they have both become ultra-orthodox and are engaged to be married. Shahar is the lead singer in a band and is studying in a Jerusalem yeshivah and Anat is in an ultra-orthodox seminary for girls. In a desperate attempt to block the upcoming wedding, Anat’s mother sends for her estranged husband who has been living in the USA. She wants his help in stopping the wedding at any cost.

In the second story, Anat’s grandfather and father are both therapists and are counseling a couple who are fighting over what is best for their young son. Both parents seem to be somewhat off balance – the father is ready to stoop to any means to keep control over his son and the mother participates in a so-called “cult” which is actually an ultra-feminist group where the women are worshipping a Canaanite goddess. 

The parallel between ultra-orthodoxy and ultra-feminism, both as forms of extremism, is quite striking. Who is to say which zealotry is preferable – extreme secularism or ultra-orthodoxy? 
    
I loved The Other Story.  It is filled with sharp dialogue, dramatic tension, multiple motivations, and in-depth characterizations. 

Tuesday, January 1, 2019

Life Within the Ultra-orthodox community


During the last year or two, there have been a lot of Israeli feature films on the subject of life in the haredi (ultra-orthodox) community.  The award-winning Geula, directed by Joseph Madmony and Boaz Yehonatan Yacov, is such a film!  It is an honest, passionate, and touching portrait of one particular man. 

Menachem works in a haredi grocery store.  Once, 15 years ago, he was the lead singer for a rock band.  But today, he is a religious man, a single father of a six-year-old daughter.  In order to earn some money, Menachem decides to search for his old friends and put together the band to perform at orthodox weddings. 

Similar to the Blues Brothers, Menachem sets out to visit each of his friends in order to ask them to help him put back together the band – for a higher cause.  In this film, it’s to help Menachem raise the funds he needs for his daughter’s chemo-therapy.

Menachem is not exactly a talkative fellow, but he does succeed in drawing us in, helping us understand who he is, and what happened to his wife.  As the wedding band becomes a success, there are problematic effects on each of his friends.  But eventually, his friends help him reconnect with his past and to come to grips with what he is searching for in his own life.

The title Geula (Redemption) is his daughter’s name. It also refers to Menachem’s searching for some sort of personal redemption as we see him change and develop within the film. 

Geula, a surprisingly compelling and touching film, filled with some great music, is available from Transfax Films.

Friday, July 27, 2018

The Unorthodox


At the opening of the Jerusalem Film Festival last night at the Sultan’s Pool, thousands of viewers had the extraordinary opportunity to see The Unorthodox, the debut feature film by Eliran Malka.

In addition, all of us who were there last night were able to honor Cinematographer, Yaron Sharf, who was presented with an award by Nechama Rivlin (wife of the President of Israel, Ruby Rivlin), for his contribution to Israeli cinema, especially for his work on this film and on many other Israeli films, including Someone to Run With (directed by Oded Davidoff, 2006) and Hunting Elephants (directed by Reshef Levy, 2013), both of which were screened at previous Festival opening events, similar to this one!

The film The Unorthodox (הבלתי רשמיים) is based on the actual story of the establishment and rise of the Shas political party (Sephardi Torah Guardians) from the1980s, until the party becomes a major force, especially in the election in 1999 when it garnered 17 seats in the Knesset. The anger, frustration, and disenfranchisement suffered by Jews of Sephardi (Mizrachi) background, at the hands of the Ashkenazi establishment and the orthodox religious Agudat Yisrael political party is depicted as the root cause of the explosion which leads to the founding and growth of this new grass roots political party. 

Our main character is Ya'akov Cohen, played by Shuli Rand—one of Israel's veteran popular actors who became ultra-orthodox in his personal life-- in a tour-de-force performance.  



Ya'akov owns a printing press and is struggling to bring up his teenage daughter who is thrown out of a “good” (read that as Ashkenazi) high school for girls.  When he realizes that she has been expelled simply due to anti-Sephardi discrimination – there is no other explanation – then he decides to take matters into his own hands.  He envisions change through the establishment of Sephardi institutions, such as schools and yeshivot, all of which will be funded by the government, and he bands together with some friends who work with him to establish an ultra-orthodox Sephardi party that will run for Jerusalem municipal elections and ultimately for the Knesset.

The narrative is about a regular guy, a working man, who has no political experience, but has the vision and the passion to make a major change within Israeli society.  This part of the film is told with tremendous humor and understanding as we get to know Ya'akov and his friends.  On another level, the film is also about politics. The director clearly expressed much cynicism and criticism of the political process that Shas underwent as it became an established political party. It seems that politics, in Israel (and elsewhere!) forces people to play dirty and even to engage in corruption!  In my view, this part of the film is not as successful as the first part, but it is nevertheless insightful and helps to explain some of what has happened to Shas over the years.

In an interview with director Eliran Malka, this morning on Israeli radio Kan Reshet Bet, Malka explained that he identifies as a Mizrachi or Sephardi religious Israeli, but he does not see himself as ultra-orthodox.  He also said that he has tremendous respect for the Shas political party, and loves the story of its founding, which he thinks is unique, but he is intentionally critical in the film of how Shas has developed over the years. 

The film provides an opportunity to understand the Shas voters, where they are coming from, and what they are expressing as part of their experience as a minority group which has suffered much discrimination over the years in Israel.  In addition, it provides insight into the workings of Israeli political life, demonstrating how  the "religious" leaders give up some of their ethical values and become poisoned by their new-found power and authority, which they abuse just like their fellow secular politicians.

The Unorthodox does not tell us much about the political platform for the Shas party, which has become well known in Israel for its concerns for "social issues", especially for the lower classes. This makes it a bit disappointing. On the positive side, using humor and pathos, the film is clever and upbeat and offers a compelling and fascinating story of one man successfully bringing about much needed social change.

I sit on the board of the Gesher Multicultural Film Fund and I am proud that we provided some funding towards the production of this film!

The film is distributed by Go2Films. 



Monday, July 9, 2018

Close-up and Personal


Driver, directed by Yehonatan Indursky, is a new Israeli feature film about personal tragedy that provides a significant look at life in the ultra-orthodox (haredi) community of B’nei Brak.  This film far surpassed my expectations and I found it to be surprisingly captivating due to the personal and compelling nature of both the genre and the story.

The driver in the film is a man who makes a living by driving needy people around town at night to visit the homes of wealthy Jews in order to ask them for money.  The driver coaches his clients on how to tell their stories so that they will be more compelling to the patrons.  These are people with large families and little income.  There is the father who wants to provide his daughter with a festive wedding but is unable to pay the bills.  There are medical tragedies.  And then there is the story of our driver and his 10-year-old daughter, whose unbelievably tragic story is slowly revealed to us during the course of the film. 

The genre of this film is quite unique – it is actually about story-telling, with many characters, both major and minor, telling the tale of their personal tragedies on-camera, in full close-up.  Although the film is minimalistic in its sets and design, the personal vignettes that make up the stories are powerful and convincing. The characters are compelling and the stories are hard-hitting, forcing the viewer to really care and worry about these people.  

In one particular shot, our driver parks his car by his apartment building.  As he enters the building to climb the stairs, the camera begins to pan upwards in a cherry-picker shot, covering the entire height of the building and then panning over the top of the building to masses and masses of similar apartment buildings in the neighborhood.  This long shot of B’nei Brak provides the viewer with an amazing revelation – in this neighborhood, there are literally dozens if not hundreds of personal stories, similar to the ones that we have been hearing!

Driver is a new feature film from United King Films.

Tuesday, January 16, 2018

New Holocaust Film

Three new Israeli feature films opened this week in Jerusalem.  I chose first to go see The Testament (העדות), directed by Amichai Greenberg, because the story sounded compelling.  A Holocaust story, it is about a modern-day investigation of an Austrian cover-up of a massacre of Jewish laborers, near the end of the war.  The film is shot both in Jerusalem and in Austria, which provides an authentic and realistic feeling to the historical story. 

Joel, the chief investigator, is an ultra-orthodox Holocaust scholar who becomes obsessed with the investigation.  During the course of his work, while he is interviewing witnesses, he stumbles upon a woman who coincidentally knew his parents, back in the Ghetto.  She gives him an old photo which leads him to dig deeper into his family’s past and to uncover a shocking discovery. This is a complex story and the news, which is tragic and shameful for him, causes him to question his own identity. 

I was disappointed in the portrayal of the main character, the Holocaust scholar, who is so obsessed with his work, that he becomes a one-dimensional character.  He is without charm, doesn’t show any warmth to his colleagues or his family members, and cannot wrap his head around the shocking news which brings him to cruelly confront his own aging mother.


The Testament portrays a fascinating slice of history, but it is a disappointing film.  

Sunday, January 29, 2017

Religious Fanaticism and Animosity towards Christianity

A Quiet Heart,לב שקט מאד  , directed by Eitan Anner, is a new feature film about life in Jerusalem.  In this film, there is a clear criticism of religious fanaticism and the haredi animosity towards Christians and Christianity. 

Naomi is a pianist who leaves her parent’s home in Tel Aviv to come to Jerusalem – to get away from the pressures of being a highly talented pianist and her fear of imperfection, and in search of solitude.  She gets a job at the radio station archives and rents a run-down apartment in the haredi part of Kiryat Yovel, where she is surprised to find a child prodigy who sneaks into her apartment every morning to play the piano that has been left there by the previous tenant. 

Not so far away is the community of Ein Kerem, where she stumbles upon an organ being played in a monastery, and feels the solitude and quiet of the church atmosphere.  As a result, she begins to take lessons on the pipe organ from one of the Italian monks. 

The best part of the film is the main character herself (played by Ania Bukstein).  The rest of the film is slow-paced and disappointing.  The secondary characters are stiff and stereotyped, especially the woman leading the struggle against the haredim in Kiryat Yovel and also Naomi’s father who comes from Tel Aviv to rescue her from the perils of life in Jerusalem.


Wednesday, July 27, 2016

The Role of the Ultra-Orthodox Woman

In a new documentary film, Measures of Merit, by Irit Dekel and Roni Aboulafia, we are offered a view of the world of Haredi (ultra-orthodox) women.  It is not easy being a Haredi woman.  They live in a man's world -- their lives are run by their husbands and their rabbis, they are harassed by the dayanim (judges) in the religious courts, and they have no representation in the Knesset.

This film offers a fascinating portrayal of one woman, Ruth Colian -- a woman who wants to change all that. She is a courageous and outspoken Haredi woman who is fighting for representation for Haredi women in the Knesset.



It would be a dramatic precedent for her to obtain a place in the Knesset.  The official Haredi point-of-view is that women have different roles in life from men.  Women must take care of the children, the home, and obey their husbands and their rabbis.  Otherwise, they begin to descend the dangerous slope towards assimilation.

But Ruth Colian believes that women's voices must be heard and that issues relevant specifically to women -- such as poverty, divorce, and gender issues -- are not being given fair treatment by the Haredi men who have been elected, who do not see themselves as representatives of women also.  In this film, we see Colian decide to create her own political party and to run for the Knesset, and we realize that this is not because she has a strong ego but rather she is motivated by a responsibility for the quality of her daughters' future.

In one of her speeches, she opens with: "It's more worthwhile to be silent, but more honorable to fight."

There are those who argue that it is immodest for a woman to be active in the political sphere and that her party contradicts the values of Haredi life.  But she cannot be dissuaded.

This is a film filled with drama and tension as election day approaches and our candidate works tirelessly, with virtually no budget, to get elected.

Measures of Merit (Hebrew title: A Jewish Woman, 49 minutes, documentary) is available from Ruth Diskin Films.

Monday, August 17, 2015

Leaving the Ultra-Orthodox World Behind



Apples from the Desert, directed by Matti Harari and Arik Lubetzky, is a modern morality tale. 



Rivka is a 19-year-old girl from a Jerusalem haredi (ultra-orthodox) family.   She is a rebellious daughter, interested in seeing the world, making a difference, and not just marrying and having children.  Her strictly religious, Sephardi parents have a love-less relationship and her authoritarian father has a cruel streak.  She finally breaks and runs away when he insists that she marry an older widower with children.  The film is an adaptation of the story bySavyon Liebrecht.  

A wonderful comic element is provided by Rivka's Aunt Sara who is the spinster aunt and has more compassion and love of life than any of the others surrounding her in her ultra-orthodox community where women are judged by the length of their skirts rather than by their good deeds. 

Rivka is helped in her escape by an intriguing young man who raises organic apples in the desert.  He brings her to his kibbutz in the Negev desert, where she slowly comes out of her shell and learns about a more open, tolerant and accepting world.  We watch as she blossoms, much as the apples growing in the desert climate.   

In this story about how an ultra-orthodox young woman breaks from her cloistered and traditional family life and chooses to live a secular, modern lifestyle, we learn about issues of family, tradition, love, compromise and acceptance.

Apples from the Desert was produced by United King Films.

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Divorce and the Haredi Community



Family Matters, directed by Noa Roth, is an intimate and fascinating documentary film that tells the story of the filmmaker's growing up, her family, how the family was ripped apart when her mother chose to take her children and leave her husband and haredi (ultra-orthodox) community behind.  Her mother, Yehudit Rotem, was a haredi woman, the mother of seven children, who today is a distinguished author.  

The mother is adamant not to appear together in the film with her ex-husband because of the difficult times that she endured at his hands.  For example, as a young mother she wanted to study and he literally burned her books.  She talks about her emotional and spiritual crisis.  She picked herself up, took her six daughters and moved to a smaller apartment, removing them from that world.  

Noa, on the other hand, although she has no intention of becoming haredi, says her mother ripped her children away from their father and their community.  Today, via the making of this film, Noa is trying to heal a deep wound that she feels still exists within her family.  Her mother and father have not spoken since the divorce, and her oldest sister, Tami, who was a teenager at the time of the divorce, doesn't speak to her father.  

This film provides an intimate glimpse into the tragedy of one family and also into the haredi world that the mother left behind.  It includes fragments from the mother's exquisite writings, using them as a mirror of that world. 

Family Matters (documentary, 66 minutes), won the Audience Award at DocAviv 2015, and is available from Go2Films.

Monday, June 29, 2015

Encouraging Understanding Between Women



I recently received publicity on a small film festival called Nashim Nehedarot which is taking place in different venues in Israel.  The festival offers films that will help to bridge the divide between ultra-orthodox and secular women in Israel.   

One of the films being featured is Barren, עקרה , a short drama by Esti Shushan.  This is a compelling portrayal of an ultra-orthodox, young woman.  Nomi is married just a few years, but her husband is terribly disappointed that they haven't been able to get pregnant.  After having already raised children as the big sister to five younger siblings, however, Nomi is ambivalent about having children.  Short and to the point, extremely well-made and touching, this film provides a different perspective on ultra-orthodox women.  

This film was produced with monies from the Gesher Multi-Cultural Film Fund.  I sit on their Board and they provide me with the possibility of previewing so many of the latest Israeli films.  Many thanks to Ziv Naveh and the staff!