"World Cinema: Israel"

My book, "World Cinema: Israel" (originally published in 1996) is available from Amazon on "Kindle", with an in-depth chapter comparing and analyzing internationally acclaimed Israeli films up to 2010.

Want to see some of the best films of recent years? Just scroll down to "best films" to find listings of my recommendations.

amykronish@gmail.com

Showing posts with label checkpoints. Show all posts
Showing posts with label checkpoints. Show all posts

Thursday, July 24, 2025

Bella is a brilliant satire about the relations between Jews and Arabs within Israel-Palestine

Here it is – my favorite film from among all the new Israeli films screened this week at the Jerusalem International Film Festival -- 

Bella represents a full collaboration between two directors, Zohar Shachar and Jamal Khalaily, an Israeli Jew and a Palestinian Arab.  At the premiere event at the Jerusalem Film Festival this week, the audience was filled with many members of the cast and crew and their families – about half Jewish and half Arab. The speakers thanked the Gesher Multicultural Film Fund which supported the film from the very beginning. (I am proud to be part of the Gesher fund.)

This is a superb satire about the political situation. It is about the friendship between two couples, who are trying desperately to get a very special dove to a competition in Jerusalem. Zohar Shachar, in her opening remarks, said that in the making of the film, they met a lot of people, both Arabs and Jews who raise doves, and they found them to be definitely interesting and sometimes weird! 

The main character in the film is apparently the dove, named Bella. Yaki and his girlfriend Limor arrive from Europe for his father’s funeral.  Also attending the funeral is Yaki’s friend Bilal (married to Nargis) who has been working for his father.  Bilal insists that Yaki’s father left him the dove and, at first, Yaki is willing to give it to him.  But when they begin reading the text messages on his father’s phone, they realize that the dove is worth a lot of money.  So, Yaki and Limor drive over to Bilal’s house in Kfar Kassem (an Israeli Arab village in the Lower Galilee) to retrieve the dove, only to realize that Nargis refuses to let her husband be cheated out of the dove.  

When Bilal and Nargis and their extended family pile into cars to go to a family wedding in the West Bank (Area A under control of the Palestinian Authority), Yaki and Limor follow them.  A road trip ensues.  There is plenty of absurdity, comedy, political references, and heightened tension. It all begins when the Palestinian police stop them in Area A and then continues throughout.

This film is brilliant in many ways.  It portrays both couples as victims of the political situation, obsessed with similar thoughts about getting pregnant and having a family, and chasing after the dove while trying to get it to the competition in Jerusalem before it is too late. 

It was clever to use the dove (the harbinger of peace) as the element that brings the two couples together. 

You can’t miss the irony and absurdity when the dove isn’t permitted to cross the checkpoint and return to Israel because it doesn’t have a permit!

Information on the availability of Bella (feature film, 75 minutes) can be obtained from Hussein Akbaraly at LOSANGE FILMS h.akbaraly@filmsdulosange.fr or through the distributor at Go2Films. 

 

Friday, October 29, 2021

Let It be Morning -- a new film by Eran Kolirin

The new award-winning feature film, Let It Be Morning, directed by Eran Kolirin, based on a novel by the well-known Israeli Palestinian writer, Sayed Kashua, is a biting political satire which won the Israeli Ophir award this year as best film and therefore will be Israel’s representative to the Oscars in the category of foreign films.  Filmmaker Eran Kolirin won this award once before with his film The Band’s Visit, but the film was rejected due to the fact that it spoke mostly English and therefore couldn’t be considered a foreign film. Let It Be Morning was in the newspapers last spring when it was chosen to be screened at Cannes, but was boycotted by the Palestinian cast because they did not agree that the film should be considered an Israeli film.

The film is about an Israeli Arab man, Sami, who works in high-tech in Jerusalem.  He is married with a son.  After attending his brother’s wedding in the village where he grew up, he finds the road back to Jerusalem has been closed, and he is stuck, not able to return home to Jerusalem, to his job, to his Jewish lover, or to his life.

Although the story is imaginary since Israeli Arab villages don’t have the roads closed and the village electricity turned off, it does however reflect a lot of reality, especially the complexity of life in the occupied West Bank.  The story is about an ongoing closure, the road out of the village is blocked for an unspecified reason, the electricity to the village has been turned off, and there is no food left on the shelves in the grocery stores.  Also, there is a secondary plot which does reflect the contemporary reality within Israeli Arab villages – the head of the town council runs the village like a hoodlum and as a result there is corruption and violence within the social fabric of the village.

Checkpoints have been the focal points of many Israeli films in the past.  Here the tightening checkpoint is part of the absurdity of the story. In fact, one of the soldiers who sits at the checkpoint is both friendly and aggressive, both eager to do his job and lazy, a sleeping serpent, so to speak.

This film, which is a bit like theatre of the absurd, also conveys a message about the inter-connection between the Palestinians within Israel who are citizens of the state of Israel and Palestinians of the West Bank who live under military occupation since 1967. Some of the West Bank Palestinians, who work in Israel, often sleep in Israeli Arab villages, which poses a dilemma for the locals who are citizens of Israel, and who sometimes harbor their cousins illegally.  This film cleverly portrays some of the impossible dilemmas of Israeli Arabs, who are in a double bind—how can they be loyal citizens of the Jewish state while maintaining their commitment to Palestinians under occupation. This puts them in psychological occupation.  It should be noted that Sayed Kashua himself found life so absurd here that he no longer lives in Israel.  He has moved to the United States.

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Using Music to Communicate across the Palestinian-Israeli Divide

 Crescendo, directed by Dror Zahavi, is a new feature film about young adult classical musicians – Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs – who are brought together to form an orchestra which will play a peace concert.  There is a nice message – music can connect us across the divide.  But it is not necessarily a feel-good film.  There are difficult issues which are exposed. This is not an Israeli film per se.  It is a German production, directed by an Israeli filmmaker, shot partially in Israel and Palestine, and mostly in the beautiful Austrian Alps.

The film begins as predictable and sentimental, with the young musicians having trouble communicating, since they are all suffering from preconceived notions about the “other.” After they undergo group dynamics exercises to get them to function together as a group, things begin to improve. At the same time, things become more complicated.

The story focuses on a few of the musicians and their issues.  And there is the do-gooder from an international non-profit organization who is running the whole program.  As the musicians share their stories, the German world-renowned conductor feels compelled to share something from his own dark past – his growing up knowing that his parents had both been doctors during the Nazi period who assisted in the mass murder of thousands of Jews at Buchenwald. We meet Ron, a promising Tel Aviv violinist, who is shockingly angry at the Palestinians whom he sees as terrorists.  And we meet Leyla, a violinist, whose mother is against her participating in the international concert because the family will be considered collaborators since she is playing music with Israelis. In addition, we get to know Omar, a clarinetist from Qalqilya, who is offered a scholarship to study music in Frankfurt. He is also involved in a “forbidden love” affair with Shira, Jewish Israeli French horn player.   

The story of the film is reminiscent of the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, conducted by Maestro Daniel Barenboim, that was comprised of musicians from Israel and from Arab countries. I heard this orchestra play at Carnegie Hall in New York City two years ago, and it was an uplifting experience. The audience applauded over and over again for the orchestra, both for their excellent renditions of classical music and for the very idea that they could play together.

 Although the film purports to be evenhanded in expressing the “narrative” of both the Palestinians and the Israelis, it is heavily critical of Israel and the occupation of the West Bank. We see the difficulties and humiliations that the Palestinian musicians have to face at the checkpoints in order to arrive at the auditions which are being held in Tel Aviv. And we witness racial and nationalistic profiling against Palestinians who are seen as terrorists by the young Jews in the orchestra.

Without offering a spoiler, I will permit myself to say that the filmmaker is commenting on the fact that Jews and Germans have succeeded in building a bridge and living together in this post-Holocaust era.  Does this imply that Israelis and Palestinians could also reach some sort of understanding, even after all the terrible atrocities which have been perpetrated by both sides against each other?

 

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

Tel Aviv on Fire




Tel Aviv on Fire, directed by Sameh Zoabi, opened this week in Israeli movie theaters.  It has already garnered awards both in Israel and abroad. The film is a superb satire about the absurdity of the Occupation, the humiliation of the checkpoints, and the chutzpah of some of the Israelis who try to make decisions for the Palestinians about what is best for them, especially IDF officers at the checkpoints.

Working for his uncle on a Palestinian soap opera, Salem has to drive regularly from Jerusalem to Ramallah to be on the set as a Hebrew dialogue consultant.  The soap opera is set on the background of the Six Day War of 1967 and is apparently popular with both Jewish Israeli and Palestinian Israeli audiences. The story is about a Palestinian woman terrorist/freedom fighter (depends on your point of view) who is assigned to seduce an Israeli general.

As Salem advances to become a scriptwriter for the TV series, we watch as he takes the story from real life and adapts it cleverly for the TV screen.  There is some romance – both in the story of the soap opera and in Salem’s own life. Yet, the strongest parts of the film can be found in the political commentary (some of it not-so-subtle, in fact quite sharp and biting), especially in the comments of the uncle about the ongoing Occupation which controls so much of Palestinian daily life in East Jerusalem and the West Bank. In addition, the film has a brilliant ending, which I will not reveal here, but leaves the viewer with the realization that the struggle by Palestinians against the Occupation will continue until it is over.

The actors in this film are all excellent, especially the lead Palestinian actor, Kais Nashif, who plays his role as someone who is seemingly aimless and easily led by others. Things get a bit out of hand when Salem turns to the commanding officer at the checkpoint -- where he finds himself humiliated on a daily basis – for advice on the character of the 1967 Israeli general.  As a result, we find Salem caught between the checkpoint officer’s view of things and his uncle’s need for underlying messages supporting the Palestinian struggle.

The filmmaker, Sameh Zoabi, is a Palestinian Israeli, who grew up in Iksal, an Arab village in the Galilee, and lives both in the USA and Israel. In a feature article by Nirit Anderman about him which appeared in the Haaretz magazine in Hebrew and in the English Haaretz this week, he shared some of his thoughts about making this film.  When asked about his responsibility to his people as a director and screenwriter, he responded, “I try to create from a very personal place… We have a greater responsibility than Jewish Israelis because our narrative is not so well known.”


Sunday, September 10, 2017

Foxtrot by Samuel Maoz

Israel’s Minister of Culture, Miri Regev, has been trying desperately to censor Israeli films and filmmakers.  Her latest attempt included heavy criticism of Samuel Maoz’s new award-winning film, Foxtrot, which she admits she hasn’t seen!  Due to the controversy over the film, I decided to go see it right away, in order to show support for it and also to see it before it is removed from Israeli screens. 

Foxtrot is a serious, strangely compelling and fascinating film, well-worth seeing!   And just today we heard the news that the film is the winner of the Silver Lion award at the Venice Film Festival!

The film is about bereavement, military service, the humiliation imposed on Palestinians at the checkpoints, the boredom and tension that the young soldiers who man the checkpoints have to deal with, and how the occupation is eating away at our soul.  Foxtrot portrays a family tragedy in a society in which tragedy is so randomly distributed among the population, as we see in the opening sequence. 



Michael Feldman is an architect (played by Lior Ashkenazi) married to a wonderful wife, with two great kids, a beautiful apartment, and a bit of a chip on his shoulder.  His son, Yonatan, is serving in a small unit (whose call name on the military radio is “foxtrot”) somewhere on the moonscape of the West Bank where they are manning a lonely and somewhat surrealistic checkpoint. 

The film is filled with metaphors and symbols.  For example, the unit’s pre-fab hut is crookedly falling into the mire of the lunar terrain, something that one of the soldiers is measuring every night, desperately worried that one day they will all disappear into the muck.  For a long time, a camel has symbolized the majestic yet lumbering and lazy Middle Eastern Arab – here it ultimately brings about our undoing. And the enormous bulldozer, which everyone associates with one of the major tools of the occupation since it is used to destroy Palestinian homes, is the instrument of a major military cover-up of tragic events at a checkpoint.  The film also offers a Holocaust allegory which highlights the terrible feelings of survivor's guilt in the second generation (the generation of the soldier's father). And the foxtrot itself -- you dance around and around but always return to the same spot.
    
This is not an easy film to watch.  It is hard-hitting and stylized, using a lot of shots from above, a perspective which makes the viewer stand back and take note.  But it is also brilliant in many ways, using the cinematic medium to portray and criticize, something that the filmmaker should be credited for and not censored! In a democratic society, this type of film which looks critically at our contemporary reality is important for raising public awareness and potentially bringing about political change.  

Foxtrot is the story of a society that is exhausted from bereavement -- smoking marijuana or simply engaging in denial are some of the major ways of coping, according to this filmmaker.  It is a brilliant and provocative film which offers a shocking and effective cinematic criticism of the military establishment.

Samuel Maoz previously directed the prize-winning film, Lebanon, about a tank unit during the early days of the War in Lebanon in 1982 and is based on Maoz's own combat experiences during that war (previously reviewed on this blog).  

Foxtrot is available from The Match Factory and Sony. 

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Eight Short Films about Coffee


Student films are fascinating to watch -- even though they might not be the best films cinematically speaking, they offer a glimpse at the subjects and issues facing young people today.  In a cross-national collaboration produced by the Film and TV Department of Tel Aviv University, Coffee-Between Reality and Imagination (Artistic Director: Yael Perlov, 2011), we are given the chance of seeing films by young Palestinian filmmakers (2 documentaries and 2 dramas) and Israeli filmmakers (4 dramas). 

The Palestinian Films
Of all of the Palestinian films, my favorite is The Clock and the Man by Gazi Abu Baker (drama, 11 minutes), based on a story by Samira Azzam.  This is a very special tale about a young man named Fathi who gets a job as a clerk in a government office.  On the morning of his first day of work, he discovers that an elderly man named Abu Fuad (Mohammed Bakri) wakes all the government workers in the town so that they can get to their morning train on time.  

Wajeh by Murad Nassar (documentary, 16 minutes) is about a coffee vendor at the Kalandia checkpoint near Ramallah.  The different metal gates and pathways make it seem like the workers are caged animals.  Wajeh is witness as the checkpoint fills with people trying to get to work early in the morning and they talk about the terrible reality of everyday life with these checkpoints.

Sense of Morning by Maysaloun Hamoud (drama, 9 minutes), inspired by Memory of Forgetfulness by Mahmoud Darwish (1987) is an art film about the siege of Beirut in 1982. 

A Cup of Coffee from Palestine by Kareem Karaja, Ameer Ahmarwo, Murad Nassar (documentary, 8 mintes) is about the bitter life stories of Palestinians living in the Al-Amari Refugee camp.

The Israeli Films
My favorite of the Israeli films in this collection is Tasnim by Elite Zexer (drama, 11 minutes), about a 10-year-old Bedouin girl living in a neglected village in the Negev.  When her father appears in a surprise visit, she runs to bring him coffee.  But she is surprised at the circumstances  of his visit.

Audition by Eti Tsicko (drama, 14 minutes) portrays an encounter between Haled and the female director/actress with whom he is auditioning to work.  At first awkward, their encounter develops.  The line between fiction and life itself becomes blurred.

A Trip to Jaffa by Eitan Sarid (drama) is a story of two illegal Palestinian construction workers who want to buy a ring for one of them who is getting married.  His family was from Jaffa, so they set off to find the same jewelry store where his grandfather originally bought the ring for his grandmother.  But things are different from what they imagined.  

Eva is Leaving by Aya Somech (drama, 15 minutes) is about a husband and wife who run a coffee shop.  He has become newly-religious and it is a point of contention between them, especially when he becomes obsessed that a cup of coffee from a non-kosher take-out pace has spilled over the vegetables in the kosher kitchen of his coffee shop.  

This set of 8 short films is available from Tel Aviv University -- films.tau@gmail.com

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Focus on a short political drama from the Ma'aleh Film School


Barriers, directed by Golan Rise, is an authentic and realistic portrayal of the issues that Israeli soldiers face at a checkpoint.  On the one hand, the young commander of a checkpoint has to deal with really sick people arriving in an ambulance, with the women of Machsom Watch who are trying to tell him what to do, and with the pressures of an intelligence alert which is warning him of a suicide bomber in his military sector. 

The film shows the complexity of the situation.  As a political statement, it justifies the existence of the checkpoint.  But as a human statement, it mourns the death and dying on both sides and it shows the terrible situations that arise on a daily basis.  The film is also about mother-son relations.  For the first time, the Israeli mother, who usually appears in Israeli films as waiting at home to hear about her son's welfare, now emerges from her home and travels to the checkpoint to confront her son concerning his behavior towards the local Palestinians.

In this short piece on youtube, you can find footage about the making of the film, including comments by the filmmaker which will provide interesting material for discussion following the screening of the film.  One of the actresses on the set comments that behind the scenes an interesting triangle was established -- there were the modern orthodox crew members, the secular actors and the Arab actors.  An interesting mix in any professional situation!
Barriers (22 minutes), a production of the Ma'aleh Film School , won the award for best short film at the Jerusalem Film Festival, 2011.