"World Cinema: Israel"

My book, "World Cinema: Israel" (originally published in 1996) is available from Amazon on "Kindle", with an in-depth chapter comparing and analyzing internationally acclaimed Israeli films up to 2010.

Want to see some of the best films of recent years? Just scroll down to "best films" to find listings of my recommendations.

amykronish@gmail.com

Showing posts with label Jews from Arab Lands. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jews from Arab Lands. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 15, 2022

A Critical Look at the Story of Sephardi Jews in Israel

 Searching for a better life and dreaming of playing their part in the Zionist enterprise, hundreds of thousands of Jews from Arab countries came to Israel during the 1940s, 50s and 60s. This film presents a story of how their rights to a better life were denied them by the Israeli government and its policies.

In her new film, The Forgotten Ones, filmmaker Michale Boganim presents us with two parallel stories – one is the story of her own father who came to Israel as an immigrant from Morocco in the 1960s.  The other is a road trip through Israeli peripheral towns, exposing stories of Mizrachi Jews of the first, second and third generations, who talk about the imbalance created within Israeli society between Sephardi and Ashkenazi Jews.  These two levels – the individual stories and the personal story of the filmmaker -- are interwoven as Boganim takes us back in history to the founding of town such as Yerucham and Dimona, where new immigrants from Muslim lands were plopped down in the middle of desolate places which prevented their real absorption into Israeli society.

In Lod, Erez Biton talks about his immigration from Algeria in 1949 and how they were moved into abandoned Arab houses. In Ashkelon, Carmel tells the story of her parents who came from Morocco.  She talks about how the children of the immigrants had no choice about their education and were forced into vocational schools in order to obtain a trade and thus “they stole generations of dreams from the children of immigrants.”  Placement in remote development towns, separation from the rest of society, and being forced into vocational training are all presented as part of the policies of discrimination on the part of the government leadership who were consciously creating a working under-class.

A major story is told about the kidnapping of Yemenite children from children’s hospital wards, where they were taken away and never heard from again, supposedly for the good of the children!!!  This is a tragedy that is currently being explored within the Israeli media, making it another example in the condescending and discriminatory practices of the early years of the State.

Reuven Abergel, born in 1942, talks about his family’s aliyah in 1948 and the humiliation of being sprayed with DDT upon their arrival, since the authorities were worried that they would bring diseases into the country.  His family was sent to Musrara in Jerusalem, a war-torn border neighborhood.

Boganim’s family story is interwoven, creatively told in voice-over by the filmmaker herself.  Her father, Charlie, frustrated and disillusioned by the failures of his life in Israel, joined the Black Panthers in 1970.  In archival footage, we hear them shouting “enough racism, enough discrimination, enough of sleeping 10 in a room.”  But the political leadership, Golda Meir in particular, reacted with disdain, condescension, and police brutality.

The Yom Kippur war apparently absorbed these immigrants and united us but erased the social struggles of the Black Panthers.  Thus, Boganim’s family decided to leave Israel and go to live on the outskirts of Paris, where they were surrounded by immigrants from Arab lands.  Unable to fully find their place there, they eventually return to Israel.

The discomfort and disillusionment exist still today in the third generation. The story of the well-known singer, Neta Elkayam, is particularly poignant.  Born in 1980 in Netivot, a development town in the Negev, south of Beersheba, she is third generation Moroccan.  Her grandparents were the immigrants and her parents were the generation that tried desperately to assimilate within Israeli society.  Today, Elkayam has come full circle. Together with Amit Hai Cohen, her life partner, she performs North African music and has become drawn to return to visit Morocco and to learn more about its culture. 

Kobi’s parents are from Morocco and were sent in 1955 as new immigrants to help found the town of Dimona.  Now at the age of 37, Kobi has left Israel to “return” to Morocco where he says he feels more at home and has taken up Moroccan citizenship.

During the discussion following the screening of the film last week at the Other Israel Film Festival at the JCC in Manhattan, Michale Boganim stated “I discovered that there was a new generation of racism in the periphery. The racism is not only a subject of the past.  It still exists today.”   For me, this was a sharp indictment of Israeli governments in the past, especially during the long reign of the Labor party in Israel, until 1977 (a political party which barely exists anymore today).

The Forgotten Ones (documentary, 93 minutes) is a serious and critical look at the story of the hundreds of thousands of Mizrachi Jews who came to Israel to be part of the Zionist dream and found themselves severely discriminated against and forced to live on the periphery of Israeli society – both physically and socially.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

Egyptian movies



Arab Movie (directed by Eyal Sagui Bizawe and Sara Tsifroni) is a documentary film about Israel TV's screening of a weekly Egyptian movie on Friday afternoons during the 70s and early 80s.  The filmmaker's grandmother came from Egypt and was glued to the TV on Friday afternoons, watching the weekly Egyptian movie.  This was weekly family get-together time. 

The film talks about the proud Egyptian family's roots in Cairo, and also about their ties to Egyptian culture and to cultural iconic figures as seen in these weekly films.  

These films were heart-rending melodramas, and all the great Egyptian singers appeared in them.  They were also musicals, political allegories and some even provided Egyptian social criticism.
There were so many cultural and political issues inherent in the screening of these films.  For example,  this was the post Six Day War period, and originally the films were being screened for the large Palestinian population.  But, not surprisingly, the films immediately became very popular with Israelis whose roots were in Arab lands.  

The director of the department at Israel TV refused to provide Hebrew subtitles on the films because his goal was definitely not to encourage inter-cultural understanding.  However, he was forced to give in to public demand and eventually the films were all screened with Hebrew sub-titles and even Ashkenazim became hooked on this cultural programming.  They say that Shimon Peres, Ezer Weizman and Moshe Dayan all watched the Friday Arabic movies.

How were the films obtained, since we did not have diplomatic relations with Egypt during this time?  They were purchased in an underground smuggling operation, not exactly legal.  The films came from the Egyptians, via the Jordanians, to local Palestinian West Bank cinema owners, one of whom regularly sold it to Israel TV.  This ended with the closure of Palestinian cinemas during the first intifada.

Arab Movie (documentary, 60 minutes), is a brilliant and compelling look at our place within the Middle East through the cultural lens.   Israelis watched these films -- but did we understand the people and their culture, especially since this was a period during which we were at war with the Egyptians?  The filmmaker's aunt, who says that she still has fond memories of her growing up in Egypt, and who lost a son in Sinai, says that she was able to feel the pain of an Egyptian's losses while watching the films. 
  
In addition to providing those who had been ripped from their lives in Cairo with the opportunity of feeling nostalgia for the lives they left behind, and with the enjoyment of the singing talent of so many of the Egyptian iconic figures of that time, the viewing of these films made us feel part of the greater Middle East, a feeling that has disappeared entirely during recent years as Israel has become more isolated. 

The film is available from Go2films. 

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Life on the Periphery




Ben Zaken is a new Israeli feature film which premiered at the Jerusalem Film Festival this week.   Directed by first-time feature filmmaker Efrat Corem, the film is about family relationships, on the background of the desperation of poverty and hopelessness in a slum neighborhood in Ashkelon.  

The story focuses on a man and his relationship with his 11-year-old daughter.  Shlomi Ben Zaken is a single father, who works as a night watchman and lives with his mother and his brother in the housing projects built in the 1950s for immigrants.  It's a sad and forlorn place, with garbage strewn everywhere.  

His daughter, Ruhi, is stealing from and fighting with the other kids.  Shlomi loves his daughter dearly, and desperately wants to provide for her the opportunity to fulfill the dreams that he had once set for himself.
 

In addition to the hopelessness, there is constant and deepening tension in the household especially between Ruhi and her grandmother, and between Shlomi and his brother.  

An ethnic drama, the film suffers from a lack of complexity.  But perhaps that is also its uniqueness -- it portrays a stifling existence, in which sad and lonely souls are ensnared by the poverty, the boredom and the terrible trap of their desperate existence.

Ben Zaken is available from Laila Films (itai@laila-films.com).
Photo credit:Amit Berlovitz


Monday, May 10, 2010

Tarab

Tarab: A Journey in Search of Memory and Identity in Two Parts, directed by Boris Maftsir, is a compelling and in-depth documentary film about our cultural identities. It provides a wealth of fascinating material dealing with issues of Arab culture, music and Umm Kulthum, combined with the story of refuseniks from the Former Soviet Union. The film takes us on a journey and provides a cultural dialogue and encounter between the renowned author, Eli Amir (Scapegoat), and the filmmaker, Boris Maftsir, between Jews from Muslim lands and Jews from the FSU.

Part I is about Eli Amir, originally Fuad Elias, who came from Bagdad at the age of 12 and was sent to school at Mishmar HaEmek (which later became the setting for his book). This part of the film is about his memories of the years he spent at the kibbutz school, his analysis of the role and depth that cultural roots play in one's life, and mostly about Tarab – the euphoria or ecstasy of Arab music. It is interesting to note that an Arab singer is called a mutreb – note the root of the word -- a person who causes you to feel the tarab.

Eli Amir talks honestly about Arab culture and how it was negated by Israeli Ashkenazi culture, how the new immigrants were made to feel inferior. Does the predominant Israeli culture look upon Arab culture in a patronizing way, even today?

Eli Amir is obsessed with issues dealing with cultural identity, the clash or border between cultures, and the importance of culture in one's life. In the third book of the trilogy that begins with Scapegoat, he clearly deals with the border or line between different cultures in a literary fashion. The story is about Nuri, the hero from Scapegoat, now an officer in the Israeli army, who meets Jasmine, a Palestinian young woman in post-Six Day War Jerusalem. Jasmine wouldn't have crossed into Western Jerusalem, therefore, the author chooses the luxurious American Colony Hotel in East Jerusalem as a setting for their encounter.

Eli and Boris go together to visit a commercial center in Ashdod, where all of the signs on the shops are in Russian. Eli's thesis is that this aliyah was not made to feel inferior, as was the aliyah from Muslim lands, and you can see it expressed in how proud they are of their culture – food, music, literature and language. It is also evident in how well they have been absorbed into their professions.

Part II – Eli's story has caused Boris to return to Riga to look for his past. He talks about the family he lost in the Shoah. Also about his daughter, Orit, who has become very connected to Umm Kulthum and her music, and this expresses itself through her work as a belly dancer. Boris also talks about his youth in Riga, and how he was arrested by the KGB and spent his first year of marriage in a KGB prison.

Boris visits Sylvia Zalmanson, also from Riga, who bravely participated in the Leningrad hijacking. She remembers how her group of friends felt that their lives were of no value if they didn't take a big risk to immigrate to Israel. As a result of her role in this hijacking, she sat in prison for four years, before being allowed to emigrate. After a professional life at Israel Aircraft Industries, today she is a successful and expressive artist.

This is a film of surprising depth and insight, providing a rich experience into two different cultural worlds. Tarab (2009, 78 minutes) is available from Ruth Diskin Films.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Film Program at Beit Avi Chai

We have been watching films and discussing them with the directors in my latest film series at Beit Avi Chai, called Fact and Fiction - Diversity Within.

Last week we saw Eli Tal-El's The Name My Mother Gave Me about Ethiopian youngsters and their roots trip to Ethiopia. Check out what Brian Blum wrote about this session at
www.thisnormallife.com

Last night, we saw Until Tomorrow Comes, a TV drama scripted and directed by David Deri. The story is about 3 generations of women in a development town (Yerucham). I have written about this film before in this blog. In a fascinating conversation, the filmmaker talked mostly about the middle-aged mother, Lillian, played by Raymonde Abeccasis (mother of Yael Abeccasis) who is not a professional actress but as a singer she certainly displayed wonderful stage presence. She plays the role of a widow -- sandwiched in between her own mother, also a widow, and her daughter, about to become divorced. Lillian is finding it difficult to love again. She states quite openly that it wouldn't be right. Deri explained that in her traditional world, she believes that it would be a betrayal of her first love, her husband, the father of her children if she were to remarry. The change comes when her mother, the aging grandmother, is put in a home for the elderly. Lillian is suddenly free of a burden -- her commitment to her mother's sacrifices also as a widow for so many years and her traditional way of life. This break from the required path permits her to finally take the hand of the man who is offering her another chance at love.